Rise of Sleeve Gastrectomy Is No Therapeutic Misadventure
Two randomized clinical trials in severely obese patients report that sleeve gastrectomy — an increasingly popular type of bariatric surgery — results in similar weight loss to traditional Roux-en-Y gastric bypass out to 5 years.
A third study reports that severely obese patients who had bariatric surgery were more likely to survive 4 years compared with similar patients who received nonsurgical treatment.
These findings were published online January 16 in an obesity-themed issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.
"Collectively, these studies provide reassuring data to suggest that the rapid switch from Roux-en-Y gastric bypass to sleeve gastrectomy in the last decade has not been a therapeutic misadventure, similar to the rise and fall of the adjustable gastric band," David Arterburn, MD, MPH, from the University of Washington, Seattle, and Anirban Gupta, MD, from the bariatric surgery program, Washington Permanente Medical Group, Seattle, observe in an accompanying editorial.
Gastric banding has almost been abandoned after being the most frequently performed type of bariatric procedure in 2008, they note.
And Edward H Livingston, MD, from the University of Texas Southwestern School of Medicine, Dallas, and JAMA Deputy Editor for Clinical Content, observed in an editorial that the three studies "demonstrate that outcomes for gastric sleeve resection — including survival, excess BMI, or weight loss, and improvement of comorbidities — are nearly as good as they are for Roux-en-Y gastric bypass, and...these outcomes are durable."
Importantly, the studies showed that many patients experience durable diabetes remission after sleeve gastrectomy, Drs Arterburn and Gupta stress.
And the rate of complications was similar with both types of surgery. However, new or worsening gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) was more common with sleeve gastrectomy, as was repeat surgery because of GERD, whereas reoperation after gastric bypass was most often for small bowel obstruction.
Swiss SM-BOSS Randomized Trial
Sleeve gastrectomy is technically easier, faster, and potentially safer than Roux-en-Y gastric bypass for weight loss in severely obese patients, Ralph Peterli, MD, Department of Surgery, St Claraspital, Basel, Switzerland and colleagues report.
Until now, however, studies comparing the two surgeries have been too short or underpowered to demonstrate midterm (5-year) efficacy.
To investigate this, they conducted the Swiss Multicenter Bypass or Sleeve Study (SM-BOSS), in which they randomized 217 severely obese adults (body mass index [BMI] ≥ 40 or ≥ 35 kg/m2 with one comorbidity) to laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (107 patients) or laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (110 patients) at one of four bariatric centers in Switzerland during 2007 to 2011.
Patients were a mean age of 46 years, had a mean BMI of 44 kg/m2, and 72% were women. About a quarter had type 2 diabetes and about 45% had GERD at baseline.
There was no significant between-group difference in the average reduction in excess BMI (> 25 kg/m2) from baseline to 5 years, the primary outcome.
That is, on average at 5 years, patients in the sleeve gastrectomy group had lost 61% of excess BMI, whereas patients in the gastric bypass group had lost 68% of excess BMI (P = .22).
However, in a post-hoc analysis, patients in the gastric bypass group had lost slightly more of their initial weight at 5 years than in the sleeve gastrectomy group (29% vs 25%, P = .02).
At 5 years, about 62% of patients in each group had complete remission of type 2 diabetes.
More patients who had sleeve gastrectomy as opposed to gastric bypass had worsening GERD (32% vs 6%).
However, rates of reoperations were similar in patients who had sleeve gastrectomy vs gastric bypass (16% vs 22%).
Patients in the sleeve gastrectomy group were most likely to have reoperations because of GERD followed by insufficient weight loss, whereas patients in the gastric bypass group were more likely to have reoperations for internal hernia.
Finnish SLEEVEPASS Randomized Trial
A second study, the Sleeve vs Bypass (SLEEVEPASS) trial, aimed to compare 5-year weight loss in severely obese patients in Finland.
Paulina Salminen, MD, PhD, University of Turku, Finland, and colleagues randomized 240 severely obese patients to receive laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (119 patients) or laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (121 patients) at three hospitals in three cities.
Patients were a mean age of 48 years, had a mean BMI of 46 kg/m2, and 70% were women.
A total of 42% had type 2 diabetes, 35% had dyslipidemia, and 71% were taking antihypertensive medications.
At 5 years, on average patients who had sleeve gastrectomy had lost 49% of their excess weight, whereas patients who had gastric bypass had lost 57% of their excess weight. Sleeve gastrectomy did not meet the prespecified criteria for equivalence with gastric bypass.
The rate of complete or partial remission of type 2 diabetes was similar in the sleeve gastrectomy and gastric bypass groups (37% vs 45%; P > .99).
Rates of discontinuation of dyslipidemia medicines were also similar in both groups, but patients in the gastric bypass group were more likely to discontinue antihypertensives after bariatric surgery.
Reoperation rates were similar in the sleeve gastrectomy and gastric bypass groups (8% vs 16%; P = .19). Repeat operations were mainly for GERD in patients who had sleeve gastrectomy and mainly for internal hernia in patients who had gastric bypass.
Bariatric Surgery Cuts Mortality Compared With Usual Care
The third study by Orna Reges, PhD, Clalit Research Institute, Tel Aviv, Israel, and colleagues, aimed to compare midterm all-cause mortality in obese patients who had bariatric surgery vs matched patients.
Among patients who received care from a large health services group in Israel, they identified 8385 obese patients who had bariatric surgery — specifically laparoscopic banding (3635 patients), Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (1388 patients), or laparoscopic sleeve gastrectomy (3362 patients) — during 2005 to 2014.
Patients were a median age of 46 years, had a median BMI of 41 kg/m2, and 66% were women.
Each patient was matched for age, sex, BMI, and diabetes status with three patients in the same health services organization who received nonsurgical management of obesity from a primary care physician.
During a median follow-up of 4.3 years, 1.3% of patients who underwent bariatric surgery died — 0.8% who had sleeve gastrectomy, 1.3% who had gastric bypass, and 1.7% who had gastric banding.
In contrast, during a median follow-up of 4 years, 2.3% of patients who did not have bariatric surgery died.
The obese patients who received usual care had a twofold higher risk of dying during follow-up compared with patients who had bariatric surgery.
Bariatric surgery was also associated with greater weight loss and diabetes remission and lower rates of new hypertension or dyslipidemia than nonsurgical care, but hospitalization and major adverse cardiac events were similar with both types of treatment.
"The evidence...adds to the limited literature describing beneficial outcomes of these...types of bariatric surgery compared with usual care obesity management alone," the authors observe.
Lessons Learned Help Patients Choose Between Sleeve and Bypass
"Several lessons from these studies can help surgeons improve shared decision making around the choice between sleeve gastrectomy and gastric bypass for the individual patient," according to Drs Arterburn and Gupta.
"Patients should be informed that deciding between sleeve gastrectomy and bypass is complex and requires patients to simultaneously consider information about many factors."
In a patient information page about sleeve gastrectomy published with the articles, Nancy Puzziferri, MD, and Jaime P Almandoz, MD, both from UT Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas, write that a patient with a BMI of 40 kg/m2 (or weight 100 pounds above ideal) can expect to lose about 60 pounds from sleeve gastrectomy.
About two in every 100 patients who undergo sleeve gastrectomy have serious complications, Drs Puzziferri and Almandoz explain, which in addition to GERD, can include blood clots or leaking or bleeding around the stomach that usually occurs within 2 weeks of the operation and can be treated.
Finally, according to Drs Arterburn and Gupta, we now need 10-year outcome data "to instill even greater confidence in these procedures," as well as studies of outcomes in patients who have had repeat bariatric surgeries and in other real-world populations.
SM-BOSS was funded by the Swiss National Science Foundation and Ethicon Endo Surgery USA. Dr Peterli serves as a consultant for Johnson & Johnson. Disclosures of the other authors are listed in the article.
The SLEEVEPASS trial was supported by the Mary and Georg C Ehrnrooth Foundation, EVO Foundation, and Gastroenterological Research Foundation. Dr Salminen has received lecture fees from Merck and Lilly. The other authors report no relevant financial disclosures.
Dr Reges and colleagues report having no relevant financial disclosures.
Dr Arterburn reported receiving institutional grants from the National Institutes of Health and Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Institute, and travel expenses and speaker honorarium from the Michigan Bariatric Surgery Collaborative. Dr Gupta and Dr Livingstone reported no relevant financial disclosures.